Skip to navigation Skip to content

BCA Chief Executive Bran Black interview on News24 First Edition


BCA Chief Executive Bran Black interview on News24 First Edition

Topics: Regulation Rumble report

E&OE

Peter Stefanovic, Host: Joining us live is the BCA CEO Bran Black. I will ask you about CPI numbers a little bit later on, Bran. But for this, on Victoria being the worst place to do business again, what are the reasons this time?

Bran Black, Chief Executive: Well, look firstly, thanks for having me on the show. I don’t think that fact of Victoria coming last will be a surprise to anybody. Unfortunately, it’s the third consecutive year that Victoria has been in that position. Its planning systems, its uncompetitive payroll tax rates, stamp duty rates, and business licensing requirements are really what sets Victoria apart, unfortunately, for all the wrong reasons, as you said.

Peter: Yeah, so, what does it need to do to free the shackles? You know, what is a government just not doing that has to be done?

Bran: Well, if you look at the other end of the spectrum, you’ve got South Australia, which has come in in first position, and again, what sets it apart is the quality of its overall planning system, so the efficiency with which you can attend to a development application or building approval, meaning you can develop more homes and you can do so faster. So Australians have the opportunity to get a foothold in home ownership.

That’s obviously a good thing here in South Australia, but by the same token, they’ve got very competitive positions relative to other states and territories in terms of their payroll tax arrangements, stamp duties, business licensing. All of those areas where South Australia does well are precisely the areas where Victoria does not do well.

Peter: So you’ve had some policy announcements in recent weeks, and we’re in election campaign, so you would expect this but Premier Ben Carroll, he’s vowed to waive stamp duty. Is that the sort of thing that’s good or is it too little, too late?

Bran: Well, obviously, if those types of reforms are put in place, then that is a good thing. For the purposes of our report, we can only count, of course, what has been implemented. So we would have to wait and see whether or not a) this promise translates into action, and then b) what that action is.

Peter: Are you encouraged at all by what Jess Wilson is proposing as the Opposition Leader in Victoria?

Bran: Well, I think what’s clear is that we do need to see action right across the board. So when the Opposition Leader, and indeed when the Government also is talking about trying to encourage more investment into that state, that is a good direction to be moving towards. But the point that I keep coming back to is that Victoria is a long way behind, and it has a lot of work to do.

Indeed, if you look at our rankings this year compared to last year, relatively speaking, Victoria has actually gone backwards. It came last in regulation and fourth in planning last year, and this year again, relatively speaking, it came last in regulation and last in planning. And what that tells you is that even though Victoria has attended to some reforms in the last 12 months, other states are moving with more reforms, and they’re implementing them faster.

So this is a race, and we deliberately try and encourage states to be pitted against one another, because at the end of the day, if they’re competing, it’s businesses, and it’s consumers, and it’s prospective homeowners that win.

Peter: So on to other states, and just briefly here, Bran but I mean, are New South Wales and Queensland showing improvements at least?

Bran: We are seeing improvements, and I might call out in terms of New South Wales, they’ve undertaken reform in terms of workers’ compensation. We will see the further benefits of that reform track through in coming years as their premiums start to be reduced. They’ve been locked in for the last couple of years.

But what we’ll also see is that the major reforms that New South Wales has put in place, and there are some pretty significant reforms in terms of planning, they will start to track through in the next 12 months and beyond that. So I’m really hopeful that New South Wales, particularly, will see an improvement in its planning performance. It moved up one spot in this year’s ranking.

Peter: Okay, and just separate to that, Bran, we’ve got some inflation data, quarterly inflation data coming out today. If it comes in hotter, would that basically lead to a rate rise next week, which would be frightening for homeowners and businesses?

Bran: Well, I’ll leave the speculation to the Reserve Bank, but what I will say is that there is so much pressure that’s already facing businesses. Businesses are feeling the pinch. We hear that from small, medium, and large businesses within our membership and beyond. The last thing we can afford to see is another bit of pressure with a rate increase, and yet speculation, of course, is that that’s precisely what’s going to happen.

What this highlights is the importance of really focusing on getting government spending under control, and importantly, having a really genuine productivity enhancement agenda that looks at tax reform holistically, that looks at industrial relations, that looks at how we can reduce regulation. There’s $160 billion worth of federal regulation alone that strangles our economy every year.

Peter: Okay, Bran Black, good to see you this morning.