Speakers: Business Council Chief Executive Bran Black
Topics: Trusts tax, gas reservation scheme
E&OE
Bran Black, Chief Executive: We’re here because the total bill that Australian businesses will face, as a consequence of the Government’s tax changes and trusts, is double our initial projections. What that means is that the first year total will be in the of the order of about $4 billion.
We’ve been opposed to these changes right from the outset. We made that position clear on Budget night. We continue to make that point.
What’s clear is that the estimate that we initially put forward with respect to these changes is in fact half of what Treasury estimates that the burden for business will be. We estimated the cost at about $900 million in a year one and ongoing basis. What’s clear is that, from evidence provided by Treasury as part of the Senate inquiry, that cost will be about $1.7 billion each and every year.
And when you combine that with the $2.3 billion that businesses will have to pay in order to comply with these changes in the first year of operation, what that means is that Australian businesses will face a total year one bill of about $4 billion. And that comes at a time when businesses can least afford it.
We know inflation is up. We know that interest rates are up. We know that businesses have low confidence across our economy. We know that business investment is down, and fundamentally, we see that productivity is down as well. What we need to do is increase our nation’s productivity. Michele Bullock makes that position very clear every time she talks, and what she says is that we need to do that in order to be able to deliver real wage increases on the one hand, and also to put downward pressure on inflation.
But we won’t do that if we have uncompetitive settings, and so we need to address the competitiveness of our settings. We can’t do that if we are increasing the overall tax burden on business. So our message to the Government is very clear on these changes to trusts: drop them, it’s not too late, drop them immediately. Very happy to answer any questions.
Journalist: Just for people who are maybe not entirely across all the details. Why would businesses put a lot of their money into trusts? Because for many people, it would seem that trusts are just a way to get out of tax obligations, that it’s a way to get around, you know, current tax, for example.
Bran: It’s a good question, and I think it goes to a fundamental misconception associated with trusts, and that is that they are used for illegitimate purposes. But what we see, and we know that colleagues across small businesses, particularly, have spoken about this at length, and that’s that trusts are used as entirely legitimate vehicles in order to manage affairs.
What that means in practice is that if you’re in business, you might use a trust to help manage your cash flow. You don’t have necessarily access to a salary that’s going to be paid on a weekly basis, or fortnightly basis, or a monthly basis, as you will if you work for a larger company, or as you might if you work for the Government. So, in order to manage cash flow, in order to try and deliver a sense of regularity for your income, you might use a trust.
In the same way, you see businesses and families, particularly that have businesses, use trusts in order to manage succession arrangements. Trusts exist in perpetuity, and what that means is, if somebody in the family dies who’s integral to the operation of the business, it doesn’t mean that the business necessarily falls over during those difficult probate arrangements.
You can continue to operate the business and you can continue to see the family’s livelihood taken care of. Those are two reasons, but there are many other reasons why trusts exist and exist legitimately in order to ensure that Australians have flexibility in the conduct of their business affairs.
Journalist: Just how confident are you that these trust tax changes won’t pass Parliament, given that the Greens have kind of signalled already that they are looking to do some sort of deal with the Government to kind of level the playing field in terms of how people are taxed, for example?
Bran: Well, our message is very clear: they shouldn’t pass the Parliament. So I can’t speculate on the likelihood of their passage through the Parliament, but I can say that it’s absolutely clear that these changes will double our initial projections as to their year-on-year costs for businesses.
Businesses across the country are going to pick up more of a bill than we anticipated, even only a few weeks ago. And so our message is very simple: set these changes aside, don’t proceed with them, they come at the worst possible time for business.
Journalist: And just on a separate issue, we’ve seen a couple of business and industry groups lend their support to a gas reservation scheme being set up, and that passing the Parliament in the next fortnight. Does the BCA also share that view? How would a gas reservation scheme help not only the BCA but also your members as well?
Bran: A good question. We do support, in principle, a gas reservation scheme. We know that we need to make sure that there is affordable gas that’s delivered, particularly to Australian manufacturers. At the same time, we know we’ve got to have the settings in place that facilitate an interest in investment in new supply for gas. We need that for our purposes here in the country now, we need it for our purposes here in our country in the future, and we also need it to make sure that we continue to be a reliable supplier to our friends and neighbours to the north.
So, for us, in principle, we wholeheartedly support the idea of a gas reservation. But you’ve got to get the settings right. What’s absolutely clear is that a deal between the Government and the Greens would be the opposite of what our country requires. That would be a dreadful outcome, and we are urging the Government and the Coalition to work together to find a way to pass these bills that is acceptable to both manufacturers and to producers, that’s what the country needs. It’s that bipartisan approach, which will deliver a practical outcome that will stand the test of time.