Topics: Trusts tax, gas reservation scheme
E&OE
Patricia Karvelas, Host: Bran Black, welcome to the program.
Bran Black, Chief Executive: Thanks so much for having me.
Patricia: You’ve done new calculations on the cost of the trust tax to business, which you say is double your initial estimate. The first year is in the order of around $4 billion. You want it dropped, but the Government’s almost certain to pass the legislation with the Greens’ support. Just going back to first principles, why is it suddenly double what you thought it would be?
Bran: Well, it’s double what we thought it would be because the estimate that was provided by Treasury officials during the course of the recent Senate hearings showed that they anticipated that businesses would shoulder about 40 per cent of the overall tax burden, and so that takes the overall burden from $900 million, which was our initial estimate, to about $1.7 billion.
And as you say, when you combine the cost associated with year one compliance to business, which is about $2.3 billion, you end up with that first year cost of about $4 billion, which is an extraordinary amount of money, and it comes at the worst possible time when businesses are already facing so many pressures.
Patricia: And do you accept that this is a fait accompli in some ways because the Greens are likely to support it with some changes. Is it about ensuring that the changes that the Greens do insist upon aren’t, in your view, too punitive?
Bran: Well, our fundamental position is that we want to see this scrapped. We continue to say that. These are bad changes, at the end of the day, as I mentioned, they increase the overall burden of tax on business at a time when we shouldn’t be doing that. We see countries around the world that are actively looking to reduce the burden of their tax systems on businesses, so that those businesses are encouraged and facilitated to invest more. That’s precisely the approach that we should be taking here.
Patricia: On the capital gains tax element, the Greens say they will look at independent MP Allegra Spender’s change proposal. Do you think that’s positive?
Bran: Well, we think it is a positive thing if Allegra’s proposal is able to proceed. Now, our fundamental position is that these changes to CGT should not proceed for a similar reason to that which I expressed just a moment ago, and with respect to trusts. But if we are to see changes to CGT, then Allegra’s model is preferred for the fundamental reason that it is more certain and it is more simple, and that will in turn give businesses greater confidence to invest.
Patricia: Okay, so if the Greens are open to it, is that promising in your view? I mean, is there really any likelihood that the Government would go to the drawing board? Because it is a very different piece of legislation it would need if the Allegra Spender model was the one they adopted.
Bran: It is a different piece of legislation, but it is fundamentally important to, I think, note some of those core differences. What you see with the proposal that the Government’s put forward is that you would ultimately have a higher tax burden, but the opportunity, if you’re a startup or an innovative business, to have a lower rate applied.
But the hurdles that you need to jump over in order to be classified as an innovative business and to continue to be classified as an innovative business on an ongoing basis are pretty steep, and that compares to, I think, a very simple analysis. What is an active business? It’s pretty easy to understand that. It’s reasonably easy to define, and as I say, therefore offers far more certainty. So, in an ideal world, we wouldn’t have these changes at all. But if we are to have them, we would far prefer Allegra’s model.
Patricia: Okay and have you reached out to the Treasurer, I mean, obviously, the Treasurer is the architect of the legislation, ultimately responsible for it, to make that argument?
Bran: We’ve certainly reached out across the board to make it plain that we see this as a model that is worthy of consideration and worthy of support.
Patricia: The Government is, of course, focused this week on passing their gas reservation scheme, you broadly support the Government’s idea here. One of the things that the Coalition’s been pushing for is that WA be carved out. The Coalition says that, you know, WA shouldn’t be subjected to something that’s going to happen on the east coast. The Government, however, says that’s basically not constitutionally okay. What’s your view on that?
Bran: Well, I can’t comment on the constitutionality of the issue. This is a point that we’ve raised in terms of a preference that we see as well in terms of, as you say, a WA carve-out. But fundamentally, what we see here is that there is an opportunity for Australia to deliver a domestic gas reservation scheme, and we want to lean into that opportunity.
But to do it and to do it properly, we have to appropriately balance the needs of producers and the need for Australia to continue to be able to guarantee supply with the needs of users and particularly our manufacturers, that need to be able to access well-priced gas, so how do we do that?
To our mind, the best way of doing it is making sure that there is a deal between the Coalition and the Government. We need the two parties of government to make the deal here. We cannot afford to see the deal that the Government does be a deal with the Greens that would have catastrophic consequences in our view.
Patricia: So, isn’t the onus then, as you frame it, on the Coalition as a party of government traditionally to compromise here?
Bran: I think the onus is on both the Government and the Opposition, and I say that because at the end of the day, both parties have had, in the recent past, or indeed do have at the moment, domestic gas reservation policies of their own. So it’s not as though we’re approaching this policy conversation with two parties that are entirely at odds. They are both trying to work towards the same outcome.
We see that there is a pathway through here, but we are saying very clearly we cannot afford to see, at the end of the day, the Government decide to partner with the Greens. We have to encourage both the Government and the Opposition to work together to get the job done. We think it can get done, and we’re confident that if those two parties work together, we can have a sustainable scheme that delivers both producers and users the confidence they’re looking for into the future.
Patricia: And is there a sense of urgency? Would you like to see this settled this week?
Bran: Well, we’d like to see it settled, but we’d like to see it settled in the right way. This has enormous implications, simply enormous implications. We know that Australia is being watched in this regard as well. I’ve been overseas recently and heard directly from investors in North Asia that they are watching very closely what we do with this scheme, and they are concerned already that some of our existing settings, not necessarily with respect to gas, but across taxation and regulation, already make it difficult for them to justify investments in Australia.
We need to make sure that we don’t take steps that make it harder for them to justify investments in new supply of gas, which will ultimately be good both for manufacturers and for the producers of gas themselves.
Patricia: The Government’s been in many meetings, as you know, last week to design its mid-year budget update, known as MYEFO. But I don’t think that means a lot to normal people. But you know, a little update on the Budget. Do you think it should be more than just a little update on the Budget? Should there be significant savings in MYEFO?
Bran: Well, we would like to see a savings focus in MYEFO. Most fundamentally, we think it’s important to send some really strong signals in terms of the Government’s intent in a couple of key areas. First, in terms of spending moving forward, and so we’d like to see the government commit to a 2 per cent cap on spending year-on-year growth.
And then, secondly, we’d like to see Australia adopt the type of measures that we’re already seeing in place in the EU and the UK, where they’ve committed to a 25 per cent reduction in the cost of red tape. Now that’s good for businesses, it’s good for putting downward pressure on inflation, but it’s also good in the sense that if you can reduce regulation, then you can also sensibly reduce the size of your public service, so there are savings to be found there, and of course, as I say, businesses benefit along the way as well.
Patricia: Many thanks for joining us this afternoon.