Skip to navigation Skip to content

BCA Chief Executive Bran Black interview on ABC Melbourne Mornings


BCA Chief Executive Bran Black interview on ABC Melbourne Mornings

Topics: Regulation Rumble report

E&OE

Raf Epstein, Host: Bran Black’s the Chief Executive. Thanks for joining us, Bran.

Bran Black, Chief Executive: Thanks so much for having me on the show.

Raf: I’m sure you heard John there. We’ve had a few people texting saying we need lots of rules and regulations. What’s your response to that?

Bran: Well, I would say that we need a sensible approach to regulation, and so there is a role for good regulation that protects people and protects competition and supports us to be safe and so forth. We entirely agree with that, but where we are concerned is where you don’t really have sensible regulation.

A good example, for instance, is that if you’re a tradie on the Gold Coast and you’re qualified as a plumber, you need a separate licence in order to be able to change a tap on the other side of the Tweed in New South Wales. And I don’t think anybody in New South Wales has ever said to themselves, ‘Well, I’m not going to use those Queensland tradies because they’re just not up to scratch.’

My point is, let’s take a sensible approach to regulation, and what we see with our annual rankings in the Regulation Rumble report that we release is that there are some areas where there is clearly scope to make a more sensible approach.

Raf: I focused on cafes because I guess it’s the the sort of business a lot of people can relate to opening, even if they’ve never opened one and you mentioned it a lot in your report. But no, no cafe is going to open up in South Australia rather than Victoria. Why focus on why is that a focus of your report?

Bran: Well, I would say that you’re going to get more businesses opening and more investment in jurisdictions that have a better approach to regulation, and I think that is pretty clear across the board that people feel more confident if they know that they have a lower prospect of being subjected to government requirements in one jurisdiction versus another jurisdiction.

So what we’re saying is that across the board, the South Australian jurisdiction has a better approach to its business regulatory and planning requirements, and that means that if you’re looking at investing in this state, or if you’re looking at starting a business in this state, you’re starting from a good spot.

Raf: This is the second year in a row you’ve put Victoria as the worst place to do business. We’ve got four weeks to go before election day almost. Is that is that playing politics, is it ideological?

Bran: Not at all. And I should say it’s the third year that Victoria’s come last. We deliver this report every year. We deliver it in at the same time every year in October every year, and we also measure the same things every year, and these are objective measurements that we use.

So there is nothing political about this; it’s all based on evidence. And as I say, we see you’ve got a Labor state in South Australia that’s coming first. You’ve got Victoria, unfortunately, for the third consecutive year coming last.

Raf: Which rule would you get rid of? Like I mentioned, a whole lot of things around cafes, permits for outdoor tables. Your grease trap has to meet two things: a food safety standard and a national construction code. You’ve got to have a licence to serve alcohol. I mean, which sort of rule would you get when it comes to opening a cafe? Which one would you get rid of?

Bran: Well, I do think we should look very clearly at advertising permitting, and with respect to music as well, and also in terms of outdoor dining. I think those are key areas where you could take either a more streamlined approach or reduce requirements in their entire.

Sorry, Bran, where music, you say, needing a permit if the music’s too loud, that sort of thing?

Bran: That’s right, and then I also see that there are some funny examples across jurisdictions where there are silly permits that apply in some states but not in others. A great example is with respect to handbills and leaflets. If you’re a cafe in Victoria you need a permit. If you’re in Brisbane, you don’t –

Raf: – to hand out a little bit of advertising, a pamphlet?

Bran: That’s right, to hand out a bit of advertising to support your operations, to support your business, and to encourage it to grow. So we would say, look very closely, as a state or as a territory, at the requirements that you’re putting on businesses, because at the end of the day, the more codes of practice or licences or permits or approvals that businesses need to contend with, the more cost ultimately that they end up passing on, and the more time that they spend devoted to that compliance function, which detracts from their capacity to invest time and effort in their business, in employing people, generating opportunity.

Raf: Just finally, the ABS still says there’s more cafes and restaurants opening than closing. That number continues to rise, not fall. Are you sure you’re not complaining too loudly?

Bran: No, when we look across the board, we see that there are so many areas in which there is scope to reduce regulation, and we know that business confidence across the board is low. And if you’re talking about Victoria specifically, we see that Victoria’s seen unemployment at 5.1 per cent, in the most recent figures. It’s led the nation in unemployment for 19 of the last 24 months. My argument would be that whatever the present statistics tell you about performance in Victoria, it is clear that there is more work that needs to be done.

And if you can improve the approach to regulation, if you can streamline operations, if you can improve planning systems, if you can cut the requirements that businesses need to attend to, that’s ultimately going to improve economic performance.

Raf: But the stats don’t quite tell that story. Like the unemployment difference between states is actually really minor, and there’s still more cafes opening than shutting. The stats actually show that the industry, the hospitality industry, is doing fine.

Bran: Well, I come back to that point in terms of the employment stats. You’re right, when you look at the statistics, you know, 5.1 per cent in Victoria versus the other figures in other states –

Raf: 4.9, 4.8, sort of thing.

Bran: Indeed, there is a small margin. What is concerning is the overall trend that I mentioned before. When you are leading the country in unemployment rates for 19 of the last 24 months, that tells you that there is a problem, and that is also consistent with what I hear from businesses.

Certainly, businesses within my membership and beyond, I hear consistently that they are not looking at Victoria as an investable jurisdiction right now because of the relative uncompetitiveness of various different settings, including those settings that we speak to in our report around stamp duty, land tax, and of course the overall speed of the planning system as well.

Raf: Thanks for your time this morning.