Topics: Trusts legislation; gas reservation scheme
E&OE
Laura Jayes, Host: Bran, I want to first ask you about your data from the BCA today about what this new trust changes would cost business. Why has this been significantly upgraded?
Bran Black, Chief Executive: Well, thanks, Laura. It’s good to be here. Look, what our data shows is that our initial estimate of the bill that businesses would pay associated with these trust changes is about $900 million. But this new data shows that it’s actually $1.7 billion, and that’s in year-on-year costs.
What that does in terms of the year one cost, the total cost that businesses will face in that first year, when you add in the cost of compliance, which is $2.3 billion, is take the total bill that businesses will pay to $4 billion. That’s coming at precisely the wrong time for business, when we need more business investment so that we can try and improve the nation’s productivity challenge, which is incredibly challenging at the moment.
Laura: Okay, you don’t really understand trusts unless you have one. Businesses use this a lot. I think the general public think trusts are used by very wealthy families to hide money from the tax office. How are businesses, your members, using these trusts, and why shouldn’t they be taxed? Why should it fall on the taxpayer, that’s the argument, really, that it’s a call, right?
Bran: Look, the key thing is that trusts are an entirely legitimate way to structure businesses, and they’ve been recommended by accountants in this regard for decades. Think about it in the context of a family business. You don’t know necessarily where the next pay check is going to come in, and you want to be able to manage your cash flows. You don’t have the certainty that comes with a regular job where you get paid on a weekly basis, or a fortnightly basis, or a monthly basis. So you need to be able to manage the cash flow.
Similarly, think about it in the context of succession, where you’ve got a family business, somebody who’s integral to that business passes away. You want to make sure that the business can continue to flow. So you set up these types of arrangements, and as I say, they’ve been set up for decades and decades.
So they’re entirely legitimate structures, and we would say this is precisely the wrong time, in any case, to be looking at increasing the overall tax burden that businesses pay, we need businesses to be focused on investment.
Laura: So, do you want this to be remodelled or scrapped altogether?
Bran: We’re saying scrapped altogether. As I say, this comes at precisely the wrong time, where you’ve got business investment down, you’ve got inflation up, you’ve got interest rates up, you’ve got business confidence down, and our productivity in this decade is on track to be the worst decade of productivity performance in a century. This is the last time, or the worst time, that you could be contemplating an increase in the overall tax burden that businesses pay. Our message is very clear: scrap these changes.
Laura: Okay, let’s talk about the gas reservation policy and energy more broadly, because we need gas, I think it was demonised for a long time. We certainly need it, but there is a tension here that it needs to be at a certain price for there to be more investment in the system. Is that happening?
Bran: Well, I think it’s entirely fair to say that we’ve got to get this gas reservation policy right. We’ve been saying consistently that a gas reservation policy well-designed is exactly what the country needs. But to get that well-designed outcome, I think fundamentally we’ve got to make sure we have a deal between the Government and the Opposition.
We cannot afford to see the Government deal with the Greens, and the reason why I say that is that both the Government and the Opposition have had, at different points in time, gas reservation policies, and so we’re encouraging them to work together to find a way through here, so that we can have a bipartisan outcome that properly stands the test of time.
Laura: Sure, but are you concerned that this gas reservation policy would require providers to sell at below cost?
Bran: Yes, that is a concern that we have, and that is one of the issues that still needs to be worked through. As a matter of principle, we do take issue with any proposal that would result, across any sector, in a business potentially being forced to sell its produce at a cost that is less than the cost that it incurs producing that product. That is a fundamental position that the BCA has, and that is an issue that we consider still needs to be worked through as part of these changes.
Laura: So from what you can see, this legislation does not have a safety net for that issue?
Bran: Well, we think there’s more work that needs to be done, but as I say, we are confident that, given the Government and the Opposition have both held policies in this regard in the past, that there is a way through this, provided it’s them that’s working together. We don’t want to see the Greens involved in this deal because, at the end of the day, what they really want to see, what the Greens want to see, is the end of Australia’s gas sector.
Laura: Okay, so the Coalition’s policies may be made pretty clear by Angus Taylor this morning. Is that sufficient?
Bran: Well, I think what we’ve seen is that there is certainly discussion that needs to be had, and we know that those discussions are occurring. We’ve heard Madeleine King talk about that this morning, and in our own discussions with Government and with the Opposition, we know that those discussions are underway, which is very useful. We want them to continue. As I said, we have to make sure that at the end of the day, this reservation is achieved through a deal between the Government and the Opposition.
Laura: Okay, let me ask you about some comments from Tim Wilson. Obviously, there’s a lot of politics in all of this, but he’s basically said that big business can fend for themselves. Are you alright with that?
Bran: Well, we say that big business, medium-sized business, small business, all should have the opportunity to rise together. At the end of the day, that’s what we need to see across our economy. It is, of course, in the interests of Australia to see small business prosper. But we know, for instance, as well, that 75 per cent of business investment comes from larger businesses.
So if we want business investment, and we know that business investment is a prerequisite for productivity, then we need to make sure that we’re putting in place policies that facilitate big businesses to succeed, as well as policies that facilitate small, medium, and large businesses. Our position is very simple: we should be focused entirely on what it is that supports all Australian businesses to prosper, because when Australian businesses prosper, that’s when Australia succeeds.
Laura: When Tim Wilson said that, what did you take it to mean?
Bran: Well, I think his point was that the Liberal Party is focused on small business to a significant degree, and that’s entirely consistent with the position that Robert Menzies spoke to back in the 1940s. But we do know that the Liberal Party has also had a strong commitment to all businesses thriving, and my position is that that’s what we need to see more of. We need to see right across the board, whether we’re talking about the Liberal Party, or the National Party, or One Nation, or the Labor Party, we need to see policies right across the board throughout the Parliament that are intended to facilitate business success because at the end of the day, that’s how we get our taxes, that’s how we get our employment, that’s how we get dividends paid that support families, but also, of course, support all of the Australians that have superannuation accounts. The 16 million Australians with superannuation accounts. We need all businesses to flourish, and those are the policies that will help us get there.
Laura: Sure, but you take this to mean that the Coalition would push for reform policies, even if big business opposed it, which could include the cost, whether it’s tax or some other mechanism that the cost of doing business in a big business would be more, even under the Coalition.
Bran: I’d have to refer that question to the Coalition. I’m not sure how we should necessarily interpret that.
Laura: Okay, fair enough. How did you interpret it, though? Are you worried about that position, or are you unperturbed by it?
Bran: Well, I would be worried by any position that would suggest that one sector or one part of the economy should thrive at the expense of another. And so our argument is very simple, and that is that the entire economy should be facilitated to improve the extent to which it can contribute to Australia’s prosperity, and so our focus has to be, as a nation, on the types of policies that are genuinely nation-building for all parts of the economy, for small business, for medium-sized businesses, and for large businesses.
And that’s why, when we talk about taxation changes as an example, we talk about holistic tax reform being the priority, because that’s how you facilitate all businesses getting ahead.
Laura: Bran Black, good to talk to you.