Skip to navigation Skip to content

BCA Chief Executive Bran Black interview on FiveAA Adelaide


BCA Chief Executive Bran Black interview on FiveAA Adelaide

Topics: Regulation Rumble report

E&OE

Will Goodings, Host: Bran, good morning to you.

Bran Black, Chief Executive: Good morning, thanks for having me on the show.

Will: So, take us through, because I reckon we’d probably have a few South Australian small business owners that might raise an eyebrow at this. What is it that sets SA apart from this regulation standpoint?

Bran: So, it’s a really good question, and what really makes South Australia excel is the overall quality of its planning system. So that means we can get more homes built here faster, but also the overall quality of its regulatory arrangements. And we look at six different settings, but specifically, what stands out for SA is the competitiveness of its payroll tax rates and thresholds, its stamp duty and land tax settings, and then also its business licensing requirements, which are very comparatively low relative to other states.

Stacey Lee, Host: Okay, so it’s purely about owning and operating a business in SA?

Bran: That’s absolutely right, and I acknowledge what you said before in terms of there being a lot of businesses that would no doubt be saying, ‘Well, I’m doing it tough right now. How does this reflect where I’m coming from?’ What we would say is that where you’ve got better settings for regulation and for planning, that means you’ve got a better prospect of riding through tough times. And we know that times are tough right now for businesses all around the country and really in all shapes and sizes.

Will: Analysing the business environment in this way, Bran, is this is a sort of story about federalism as well? I mean, it’s peculiar that we have six different systems and sets of regulations for businesses to operate in the same country.

Bran: Yeah, it is a really interesting question because we find ourselves caught from time to time between thinking, ‘Well, wouldn’t it be great if we just had one system across the board.’ But on the other hand, it’s good to be able to drive a little bit of competitive federalism, if I can say that.

If you look at your payroll settings, we like the fact that states are going to compete with one another on who can have the lowest payroll rate and kick it in at the highest possible threshold. Meaning, of course, ideally, you’re capturing fewer and fewer businesses, we want states to be competitive on that.

But what we don’t want states to be competitive on is the kind of settings that sit behind that. So, what type of payments are captured? It’s that sort of thing that creates a nightmare for payroll managers and offices within companies around the country. And if you can have consistency on those types of issues, that would be terrific.

Will: Is there momentum in a positive direction broadly speaking when it comes to regulation in Australia at the moment, Bran?

Bran: Look, we’ve got too much, there’s no two ways around that. If you look at federal regulation alone, it costs about $160 billion a year. That’s is the equivalent of almost six per cent of our GDP. So there is an enormous amount of work that we need to do to start reducing regulation in a meaningful way.

What we have consistently said is that the federal government should set a target to reduce regulatory costs by 25 per cent by 2030. That is the same target that the EU and the UK have already put in place. We would make the point that every state and territory in Australia should be doing the same thing.

As we’ve just mentioned, businesses are doing it tough. If we can give governments the discipline of actively seeking to reduce regulation, then that ultimately means that businesses don’t have to spend as much time and money on compliance, and that translates into lower costs for customers, which is better for everyone.

Will: Well, good to be number one, Bran Black, the Business Council of Australia CEO on the Regulation Report that has again South Australia on top.