Topics: Regulation Rumble report
E&OE
Emma Rebello, Host: The Business Council has ranked every state and territory based on rules and regulations. So, which jurisdiction came out on top? We’re joined from Adelaide. Bit of a hint there by the Business Council CEO Bran Black. G’day, Bran.
Bran Black, Chief Executive: G’day. Thanks for having me on the show and yes, that is very much a hint.
Emma: It is a hint. Okay, so tell us which state came on top for starting up a business.
Bran: So for these rankings, this is the fourth consecutive year we’ve seen South Australia come out on top, and that’s really quite the achievement. What sets South Australia apart is the quality of its planning and its regulatory arrangements, and that’s what we look at in this report.
South Australia does particularly well in terms of its payroll tax settings, but also its competitive stamp duty land tax arrangements and its business licensing arrangements as well.
Emma: So this report looks at quite a few different areas. How did you compare all the various jurisdictions, and did anything surprise you?
Bran: So what we’ve done over the course of the last few years is compare consistently across those two categories, regulation and planning, 10 different subcategories. So, in the regulatory side of things, we look at stamp duties and land taxes. We consider payroll tax rates. We look at business licensing arrangements and retail trading hours. We consider workers’ compensation premiums, and we also look at stamp duties on insurance.
And then on the planning side, we consider what we describe as efficiency, consistency, certainty, and transparency. And that really goes to the overall strength of a planning arrangement, which in turn dictates how well you can go about getting more homes out of the ground and more Australians in homes faster.
What we’ve seen is that over the course of the last three years, particularly, the race has tightened. So whilst South Australia has come out on top, we’re seeing that other states are increasingly becoming more competitive across all areas, and that’s a great thing because ultimately it means lower costs for consumers, and as I said before, more homes getting built faster.
Emma: Well, South Australia came out on top, but Victoria got the wooden spoon again. It’s already got a big splash on one of the papers this morning. Why is it last, why is it at the bottom of the list? And is it a long way down the bottom, or does it take just a little bit to catch up to some of the others?
Bran: Well, as I said before, the race has tightened somewhat. But what is concerning and a bit disappointing is that Victoria has actually gone backwards, relatively speaking, compared to where it was last year.
So, in last year’s report, Victoria came in last place with respect to the regulatory settings, but fourth place, so in the middle of the pack in terms of the quality of its planning settings. This year it’s come in last place on both of those planning and regulatory measures, and that’s really a very solid wake-up call. We need to move forward with Victorian planning reform and regulatory reform, and we have to do it at pace. As I said before, the race has tightened, and that’s a great thing and what that means is that all states, whilst they might be undertaking reform, they need to move forward faster in order to get ahead in the rankings.
Emma: How much of an issue is this for businesses if they want to set up, are they looking at a lot of these things before choosing which state to go to?
Bran: That’s what we see, and we’ve certainly put together this criteria, those 10 factors that I mentioned before, having regard to direct feedback from businesses, small, medium, and large, as to what matters to them when they’re making investment decisions.
When you consider those 10 points that I raised before, they’re all points that affect all businesses of all sizes. So what we’re really trying to do is say, if you’ve got quality settings, you’ve got more prospects as a jurisdiction of securing more investment, therefore creating more jobs in your state or your territory. And that’s the kind of thinking that we’re trying to encourage by producing this report.
Emma: How much of a headache is it for businesses having to deal with different states and territories and so many different rules and regulations?
Bran: Look, it’s a major headache, and I think payroll tax is one of the key areas that stands out in that regard. If you consider that there are 36 different categories of payment that are covered by payroll tax rulings across the eight states and territories in Australia, but only 10 that overlap across all eight states and territories.
So you’ve got 26 that are inconsistently applied, and that’s very difficult for any business operating interstate, and particularly those that operate in every state, and that’s just one example. So where there is scope for harmonisation, we would always say do it, but we would also always make the point that where there’s scope to be competitive on settings like the payroll tax rate, or alternatively the threshold at which it applies, that’s good if states can be competitive with one another, because ultimately, as I say, it’s businesses that benefit with lower costs that they can therefore pass on in terms of savings to consumers meaning, you’ve got more money in your back pocket at the end of the working week.
Emma: Bran, are government’s listening closely enough?
Bran: Well, we are seeing, as I say, that this race is tightening, and I see over the course of the last few years that we’ve been preparing this report, that we have much more interaction with governments all around the country and at federal level in relation to this report as well, where we’re being asked consistently by premiers and by treasurers, ‘What do I need to do in order to improve the rankings?’
These types of requests for information have become so frequent that we’ve actually taken the step earlier this year of writing to every government, saying ‘We’ve been working with you over many months now. You might recall that these were the areas where you didn’t do so well in the 2025 edition. This is where we’d like to see you improve for the 2026 edition’, and we’ll continue to do that.
Emma: Bran Black, thanks for your time.
Bran: Thank you so much for having me.