Topics: Regulation Rumble report
E&OE
Jules Schiller, Host: Bran Black is the Chief Executive of the Australian Business Council. He joins us now. Bran Black, good morning to you.
Bran Black, Chief Executive: Good morning. How are you?
Jules: Let’s start with the positive news. What makes South Australia a good state to do business in?
Bran: Well, South Australia is very competitive right across the board. It’s got a quality planning system, but perhaps more importantly, its regulatory settings really do set it apart. So it’s got a low payroll tax rate, a high threshold, obviously a very good thing. It’s got competitive approaches to stamp duty, to land tax, and also business licensing arrangements. That’s what makes, on the whole, South Australia the best place in Australia in which to do business.
Sonya Feldhoff, Host: You mentioned planning, but we’re not the best in the country around planning. I think it’s Tasmania, isn’t it, who does better on that front?
Bran: That’s correct this year, South Australia did, in fact, come first last year. But what’s happened in the last 12 months is that Tasmania has done a lot of reform, and we’re more importantly, we’re starting to see the fruits of that reform that translate into faster approval times. And obviously, that’s a good thing because the faster the approval time, the more scope you’ve got to get to more homes developed faster and more Australians into homes.
Jules: Bran, two sectors we don’t do well in is insurance and retail hours. Why are we last in insurance?
Bran: Well, that really comes down to the duties that are applicable to insurance costs, and what we’re saying here is that South Australia’s got an uncompetitive approach to this particular metric. There are states that don’t require any payment in this regard, that’s obviously the gold standard, that’s what we’d like everybody to be moving towards.
But our message to South Australia, in terms of those two points that you mentioned, retail trading hours and duties on insurance, is there is scope to improve, and we want to see that improvement.
Sonya: We’ve got to look at retail trading hours because South Australia is the butt of many a joke due to our retail trading hours. What could we be doing better on that front?
Bran: Well, if you look at territories, for instance, the ACT and the Northern Territory, they don’t have any restrictions on their retail trading hours. And again, we would say that’s the gold standard because you’re leaving it to businesses to make the call as to what works for them. They know what markets they’re pursuing, they know what their audiences are, if you wish, and as a consequence of that, we would say give them the scope to make the call for themselves as to when they’re open and when they’re shut.
Jules: Well, I mean, the argument in South Australia is it protects local supermarkets, you know, by having you know these restrictions in place on public holidays and weekends and stuff, Bran Black. I mean, you accept that that is an argument against it?
Bran: I certainly understand the argument, but I would always say that it’s the interests of businesses to make the call as to what works for them best in terms of when they’re open, when they’re shut.
Sonya: So, when the Business Council does this report each year, does that actually see people moving from state to do business, I mean, does it actually have a, you know, a tangible impact?
Bran: Well, we know that states certainly make changes based on this report. I get lots of different queries from premiers and from treasurers and from planning ministers, all throughout the year. So many that we’ve started writing to states at the beginning of each year, saying, ‘This is where you didn’t do so well. These are the areas that we’d like to see you improve on in future reports.’
And the great thing that I would say is that in this iteration of Regulation Bumble, so the 2026 edition, we’ve seen that the field has tightened a lot compared to when we started doing the report three years ago. So that’s a great thing. And what we know is that if you’ve got better conditions, you’ve got more prospects of getting people to start businesses, or for businesses to invest more. That’s just what we see right across the board when we have better approaches to regulation, better approaches to planning.
Jules: Now, obviously, this is a look at, you know, regulation and various states’ approaches to that. But what’s confidence like in the business community at the moment, Bran?
Bran: It’s a really good question because we do see right across the board when I’m talking to businesses that they are deeply concerned about our position right across the country. We’ve, of course, got a challenge with respect to inflation, we see that productivity is very low, we see that business confidence is very low as well, and what that means is that, as a nation, but also as states, we genuinely have to embark on a real process of trying to drive productivity-enhancing reform.
These are difficult reforms that we’re talking about at the federal level, but there’s lots of work that states can do as well. And our report that we’re releasing today is intended to encourage states to do even more reform that we know is ultimately in the interests of driving better outcomes for people across all jurisdictions, and ultimately, ideally, a bigger pie that we can all share from.
Jules: Bran Black, Chief Executive of the Australian Business Council. Thank you for your company this morning.