The Business Council of Australia (BCA) welcomes the opportunity to make a submission on the draft Secure Australian Jobs Framework (Framework) and proposed amendments to the Commonwealth Supplier Code of Conduct (Supplier Code). The BCA is a member-led organisation representing more than 120 of Australia’s leading employers.
The Commonwealth Government must not introduce procurement rules that increase the risk of corruption and higher costs in the awarding of taxpayer-funded contracts, while making Australia’s productivity crisis even worse. Decisions involving taxpayer funding on this scale must be based on value for money and who can effectively deliver the product or service.
The BCA is deeply concerned that the Framework and the proposed amendments to the Supplier Code risk undermining these principles by favouring businesses with union-covered enterprise agreements. As the investigations in Victoria and Queensland have shown, this approach carries unacceptable risk for the taxpayer and the economy.
The Commonwealth’s proposed changes risk embedding this rotten approach across the economy and to many industries and services beyond construction.
At a time when Australia is facing a productivity crisis, these changes will further compound that problem, making the task of improving living standards for all Australians even harder.
The proposals would give unions greater influence over who wins taxpayer -funded work, without requiring better value for money. The preference for union-covered enterprise agreements would be incorporated into Commonwealth contracts, with four significant consequences:
- Better-paying businesses can be disadvantaged. A supplier offering higher wages and better conditions can be assessed less favourably for Commonwealth contracts than a lower -paying competitor, simply because its enterprise agreement does not cover a union.
- Businesses without union-covered agreements have no clear way to meet certain Supplier Code workplace requirements. Those without an enterprise agreement must demonstrate conditions above applicable awards and prevailing industry standards, using employers with enterprise agreements as comparators. But the drafts do not explain how that comparison will be made or what benchmarking evidence will be accepted. Businesses with non-union agreements are not offered a benchmarking option.
- A union-covered agreement could become the only practical way for some suppliers to secure Commonwealth work. A supplier that cannot meet enough other workplace criteria may need a union-covered agreement to satisfy the Supplier Code, even if it already provides good pay and conditions.
- The Supplier Code would extend the integrity risk to subcontractors. Commonwealth contracts generally require suppliers to comply with the Code. The union -covered agreement preference would therefore become part of their contractual obligations. Head contractors would also have to ensure their subcontractors comply with the Code. Failure to comply could put both government contracts and subcontracting work at risk. Smaller businesses, with fewer resources to absorb additional compliance costs, could be shut out of these supply chains, narrowing the choice of specialist suppliers and subcontractors available to larger businesses.
A supplier generally needs a union’s cooperation to secure a union-covered agreement. This creates opportunities for improper demands, favouritism and exclusion. Corruption cases in cleaning and horticulture show that these risks extend beyond construction. Permission to submit a tender does not remove these pressures.
The Government should not proceed with these changes. If it does, it should at a minimum not finalise them until the Royal Commission into the Integrity of Major Public and Civil Infrastructure Construction Projects in Victoria (Victorian Royal Commission) has delivered its final report, and the Commonwealth has considered and responded to its findings. The Royal Commission is examining whether procurement and workforce arrangements on taxpayer-funded projects enabled misconduct. It would be reckless to extend similar arrangements to other industries before its findings are known.
These proposals undermine the competition and productivity improvements Australia urgently needs. Labour productivity has gone backwards by an average of 0.1 per cent a year over the past six years. Discouraging competition on price, quality and innovation could leave taxpayers paying more without securing better jobs or services.
Compliance with applicable workplace laws and the existing Supplier Code should satisfy the workplace standards required for Commonwealth work, while preserving agencies’ ability to specify skills and capabilities needed for a particular contract.
The Government should publish its promised assessment of costs, benefits and effects on competition before finalising any changes. This submission sets out practical recommendations to help ensure that the Framework and Supplier Code promote good workplace practices, encourage fair competition and secure quality goods and services that deliver value for taxpayers.