Skip to navigation Skip to content

Submission on the minimum tax on discretionary trusts – exposure draft legislation


Submission on the minimum tax on discretionary trusts – exposure draft legislation

The Business Council of Australia (BCA) thanks Treasury for the opportunity to provide feedback on the exposure
draft legislation to implement a minimum 30 per cent tax on discretionary trusts.

The BCA represents over 120 of Australia’s largest employers. We develop and advocate for policy that raises
living standards for all Australians.

Australia has an urgent task to lift productivity, grow real wages and improve living standards, but the proposed
30 per cent minimum tax on discretionary trusts will not deliver on this need.

Instead, the proposal will increase tax complexity, compliance costs and uncertainty, including for commercial
trust structures that have no capacity for income splitting. While the revised proposal addresses some concerns
raised in the previous consultation, significant issues remain.

The consultation period of 15 days for this measure is inadequate for changes of this complexity – particularly
given the substantial changes since the previous consultation. Insufficient consultation increases the risk of
unintended consequences, higher compliance costs and further legislative amendments. The BCA recommends
that all future consultations on the trust tax measures run for at least 30 days.

The expanded definition of a fixed trust could address some of the concerns raised in submissions, but its use of
undefined terms such as “material” and “significantly” still involves uncertainty. The proposed treatment of trust
deed amendments and trustee discretions could also bring managed funds and employee share trusts within the
minimum tax, despite the stated intention to exclude them. The scale of superannuation investment through
trusts makes certainty about the treatment of these structures particularly important.

The legislation should give clear effect to the exclusions described in the explanatory material, including by
expressly excluding managed investment trusts, registered schemes, employee share trusts and foreign resident
trusts. Ministerial discretion should be limited, with exclusions specified in primary legislation wherever possible,
and the discretion, where retained, should promote certainty.

The BCA also recommends several changes to ensure the legislation meets the policy goals, including payments
which are untaxed by policy design should be excluded from the minimum tax and punitive taxation should be
removed from listed or public companies.

Effective transition arrangements are essential. The Government should continue negotiating the broadest
possible state and territory stamp duty relief for restructures. The frameworks for rollover and Excluded Election
Trusts should be in place at the same time so taxpayers can make informed decisions about these mutually
exclusive and irrevocable options. Further clarity is also needed around the potential stamp duty and trustee-duty
implications of electing into the Excluded Election Trusts regime.

Finally, serious consideration should be given to replacing the minimum tax with a withholding tax approach,
which may achieve the policy objectives with less complexity and fewer consequential interactions. If this
alternative is not supported, the reasons should be explained in detail as part of the policy’s Impact Analysis.

Read our full submission here.