The Business Council of Australia (BCA) counts more than 120 chief executives from leading companies across the Australian economy as members. Our members include companies directly involved in EPBC Act assessments and approvals, including in the mining and resources, energy, property, infrastructure and legal sectors. Our membership also has a strong interest in achieving positive environmental outcomes for the nation.
The BCA supports restoration contributions as an additional way for proponents to meet offset obligations. A well-designed system can reduce the time and cost of acquitting offsets and allow funds to be pooled for restoration at a scale that individual offsets rarely achieve.
These benefits depend on charges that are proportionate to the cost and risk of delivering the required outcome, and that proponents can predict and reproduce. Charges need to be designed to ensure that environmental outcomes can be confidently delivered, without being so conservative that they make restoration contribution payments unusable. We recognise that this is a tension that the Department is grappling with, and needs to get right.
At this stage, it appears that the appropriate balance has not yet been achieved. Taken together, the assumptions and allowances in the proposed methodology risk producing charges that are cost prohibitive. Where proponent-led offsets are not practical, this could make development in Australia uncompetitive and uneconomic, with significant implications for new housing and for key sectors such as critical minerals. Calculator outputs should be tested against the observed costs of comparable offsets before the calculator commences.
In particular, the BCA is concerned that:
- The paper provides limited detail on inputs, assumptions and supporting tools, that proponents need to understand or reproduce a charge.
- The paper does not describe an avenue for proponents to rely on better evidence where a default assumption is not representative.
- A single reversal multiplier applied to the whole sub-total means projects with the same restoration costs and reversal risk pay different contingencies depending on land values, and the contingency is retained where no reversal occurs.
- Cost uncertainty, the management reserve and the reversal contingency each add a separate allowance. Their combined effect is not shown, but in the paper’s case studies the contingency alone equals or exceeds the restoration costs. It is also unclear how estimated land values are converted into access costs.
- It is not clear when a charge becomes fixed or when it must be paid.
This submission builds on our October 2026 submission on the exposure draft of the regulations, which addressed related matters including maintenance periods for restoration actions, state offset schemes, and marine protected matters.