Skip to navigation Skip to content
Regulation Rumble 2026

Regulation Rumble 2026

The need for better regulation

Australia cannot tax, regulate or redistribute its way to higher living standards. We have to grow and we have to become more productive.

This is the fourth year that the BCA has prepared our Regulation Rumble comparison of the states and territories to identify good regulatory and tax settings and practices across Australia.

The BCA prepares Regulation Rumble to identify good regulatory and tax practices across Australia, to highlight what is working well and encourage states and territories to learn from each other.

For the fourth year in a row, the report compares state and territory planning systems, payroll taxes, land taxes, licensing, and other regulation that may be holding back business activity across Australia. This year, we have added to the scope, ranking insurance levies charged by the states and territories, and have expanded the metrics used to assess planning system performance.

By combining the ‘cost and regulation ranking’ together with the ‘planning ranking’ we identify the best jurisdictions in the nation in which to do business.

The need for better regulation is now a welcome feature on the national policy agenda. All states and territories should strive for best practice regulatory settings. In the coming years, as reforms and changes occur, we hope to see jurisdictions rise up the ranking as they seek to outperform others in a race to the top. Together this will lift Australia’s productivity and facilitate further business investment and employment growth.

 

SCORECARDS

Identifying Australia’s best places to do business

A competitive tax system, and effective and efficient regulation, are part of the economic fundamentals necessary for a more resilient, diversified, and dynamic economy — the current patchwork of regulation across the nation discourages investment and is a barrier for companies to expand and trade across state lines or overseas.

The annual scorecards compare how every state and territory performs on regulation, taxation, and planning systems — the essential ingredients that shape where businesses invest, grow, and create jobs.

The BCA has selected metrics that impact businesses across the nation, imposed at a state and territory level, to rank how jurisdictions perform in relative terms.

Jurisdictions that achieve a higher ranking are generally better placed to capture business investment and support employment growth. The rankings are from a business and customer perspective.

There are three “Best in 2026” scorecards and ten individual scorecards across two distinct areas: cost and regulation, and planning systems. This year, we have also identified the best features across the nation.

BEST FOR BUSINESS IN 2026


1st    South Australia

2nd  Tasmania

3rd  Australian Capital Territory

4th  Northern Territory

5th  New South Wales

6th  Queensland

7th  Western Australia

8th  Victoria

In 2026 South Australia has the best regulatory and tax settings for doing business in Australia. This is the fourth year that South Australia has topped the Regulation Rumble rankings.

Our comparison finds that South Australia comes out in front in terms of its payroll tax system. The state also ranks in the top three performers for property taxes and charges, business licensing, and its planning system. These are consistent elements of the South Australian regulatory system over the last four years. Other jurisdictions are working to improve their planning systems and their licensing requirements, and there has been movement in those areas of the rankings; but South Australia is also working to better its absolute performance in those elements.

Meanwhile, no other state or territory has undertaken comprehensive or substantial positive changes to their payroll or property tax systems which helps South Australia score so well and remain ahead of other jurisdictions in these rankings.

South Australia does however have room for improvement. It still has restrictive retail trading settings compared with much of the nation and ranks last in terms of insurance duties. Generally, however, in comparative terms today, the state still provides the best overall environment in which to do business.

Amongst the states and territories, Victoria again has the most work to do in improving its business environment. This has been the case year after year now. This is not to say everything is negative, as Victoria performs well in terms of its insurance duty ranking, and has improved its business licensing ranking.

But the state remains at or near the bottom of the ranking for property taxes and charges and payroll taxes. While business licensing requirements have improved, those remain towards the bottom of the ladder when compared to the rest of the nation. It has also fallen significantly in terms of the state’s planning system. Many of Victoria’s most significant reforms will not come online until 2027, while other states are already implementing their reforms. All of that heavily weighs down the state’s performance. That means Victoria continues to have much room for improvement to make it competitive from a business perspective.

 


1st   South Australia

2nd Australian Capital Territory

3rd  New South Wales
          Northern Territory

5th  Tasmania

6th  Queensland

7th  Western Australia

8th  Victoria

This master scorecard ranks the states and territories’ taxation, regulatory cost, and trading regulation from a business perspective. It brings together six elements. Each element is expanded on in its own scorecard:

  • Taxes on employing workers (payroll taxes)
  • Charges for owning property (land tax and stamp duty)
  • Flexibility of retail trading hours
  • Cost of workers compensation schemes
  • Licensing and requirements to do business
  • Cost of insurance duties

 


1st   South Australia

2nd  New South Wales

3rd   Queensland

4th   Northern Territory

5th   Tasmania

6th  Western Australia

7th  Victoria

8th  Australian Capital Territory

Payroll tax is an additional cost that businesses must absorb when they hire more staff. A national business must also deal with eight different payroll tax regimes with differences in rates, thresholds, scaling systems, exemptions, and  administration across the country.

What was measured?

  • Highest payroll tax rates charged (including levies and surcharges)
  • Thresholds for when payroll tax is applicable
  • Payroll tax rates charged for different payroll sizes
  • Alignment of payroll tax revenue rulings

 


1st   Australian Capital Territory

2nd  Tasmania

3rd  South Australia

4th  Northern Territory

5th New  South Wales

6th  Western Australia

7th  Queensland

8th  Victoria

Land tax and stamp duty are significant contributors to the cost of doing business when holding or transacting land and property.

What was measured?

  • Highest stamp duty amounts charged
  • Stamp duty rates charged for different property values
  • Highest land tax rates charged
  • Land tax rates charged for different land values

 


1st  Australian Capital Territory
        Northern Territory

3rd Tasmania

4th Victoria

5th  New South Wales

6th  Western Australia

7th South  Australia

8th  Queensland

Restrictions on retail trading hours can limit business sales by preventing businesses from operating at times that best serve their customers. These limitations can lead to inefficiencies in business operations, adding an extra cost and burden for businesses.

What was measured?

  • Legislated restrictions on regular day retail trading
  • Legislated restrictions on public holiday retail trading
  • Exemptions available from trading restrictions

 


1st   Queensland

2nd Western Australia

3rd  Australian Capital Territory

4th  Victoria

5th  South Australia

6th  New South Wales

7th  Tasmania

8th  Northern Territory

Workers compensation is a compulsory form of insurance paid by most employers in Australia. It provides important protections to employees if they suffer a work-related injury or illness, which the BCA supports.

What was measured?

  • Average premiums as a percentage of wages

 


1st   South Australia

2nd Northern Territory 

3rd  Queensland
         Western Australia

5th  New South Wales

6th  Australian Capital Territory

7th   Victoria

8th  Tasmania

The complexities and variations in business licensing, regulation and codes of practice across Australia significantly impact businesses, particularly small ones. Increased administrative burdens, delays in obtaining necessary licences, and compliance risks can lead to higher cost and act as barriers to growth.

What was measured?

  • Indicative number of licences, regulations, and codes of practice required for a small café
  • Indicative number of licences, regulations, and codes of practice required for a small childcare service
  • Indicative number of licences, regulations, and codes of practice required for a small clothing, footwear, and accessories retailer

 


1st   Australian Capital Territory

2nd Victoria

3rd  New South Wales  

4th  Queensland  

5th  Tasmania

6th   Northern Territory
           Western Australia

8th   South Australia

Insurance duties are taxes imposed on the payment of insurance premiums. These duties impose direct costs on businesses and add regulatory complexity.

What was measured?

  • The general insurance duty rate
  • The professional liability insurance duty rate
  •  The compulsory third party (CTP) insurance duty rate

 


1st   Tasmania

2nd South Australia

3rd Northern Territory

4th Western Australia

5th Australian Capital Territory

6th Queensland

7th New South Wales

8th Victoria

This master scorecard ranks the nation’s planning and building permitting systems from an applicant’s perspective. It brings together four elements. Each element is expanded on in its own scorecard:

  • Efficiency
  • Consistency
  • Certainty
  • Transparency

 


1st  Tasmania

2nd Northern Territory

3rd Western Australia

4th South Australia

5th Queensland

6th New South Wales

7th Australian Capital Territory

8th Victoria

The core of any planning system is its permitting and approval processes.

What was measured?

  • Average time for development applications valued under $30 million
  • Average time for development applications valued at over $30 million
  • Average time for construction approval post-development application
  • Average time for proponent-initiated and planning authority code amendments, or rezonings
  • Residential building approvals per capita
  • Reduction of decision timeframes for development applications from the previous year

 


1st   South Australia

2nd Australian Capital Territory

3rd Tasmania

4th Northern Territory

5th Victoria

6th New South Wales

7th Western Australia

8th Queensland

Consistency in processes underpins and drives efficiency in planning systems. It makes interactions between the thousands of applicants and multiple planning authorities more predictable and routine, and easier for businesses to navigate.

What was measured?

  • Standardised planning instruments across the jurisdiction
  • Standardised zoning that provides clarity of interpretation and application
  • Number of planning documents beyond standard instruments
  • Whether proponents can initiate
    rezonings and planning scheme
    amendments (such as re-zoning
    applications)
  • Specific mining and energy planning initiatives, in the context of the transition to a clean energy future
  • Whether there are planning reforms and programs in place consistent with the
    national goal to increase housing supply

 


1st  Tasmania

2nd Queensland

3rd South Australia

4th Western Australia

5th Australian Capital Territory

6th Victoria

7th New South Wales

8th Northern Territory

Certainty in the planning system supports and drives efficiency. It enables project proponents to plan their delivery and operational needs with confidence. A lack of certainty in planning systems creates added risk and cost of delay, which impacts a project’s feasibility, reducing the likelihood a project may proceed.

What was measured?

  • Whether a statutory timeframe is prescribed for deemed decisions by planning authorities on development applications
  • Limits on ‘stop-the-clock’ provisions that allow a planning authority to stop an assessment and seek additional information, and whether applicants can constrain their use
  • Availability of delegations to streamline bureaucracy and simplify procedural processes
  • Whether there are simple pathways for implementing developer contributions.
  • Whether there are prescribed statutory timeframes for building regulators to make a building application decision
  • Whether statutory timeframes are prescribed for planning authorities to make plan amendment decisions/rezonings
  • Whether legislative or regulatory action has delivered on policy commitments.
  • System-wide reform compared with targeted, more limited reform

 


1st  New South Wales

2nd South Australia

3rd Victoria

4th Australian Capital Territory

5th Northern Territory

6th Tasmania

7th Queensland

8th Western Australia

Transparent planning processes allow applicants to understand how efficient a planning system is and help governments understand good and bad performance in the system. They inform those responsible for the system on what is working and where there should be intervention, fostering an environment of continuous improvement.

What was measured?

  • The extent of online web portals for applicants to view planning controls and track and lodge applications
  • The extent of open data provided about development application process
    performance
  • The extent of open data provided about planning scheme amendment
    performance
  • The extent of open data provided about building approval performance

 

States and territories should follow each other’s lead by adopting the best features from across the nation.


Cost and regulation:

  • Competitive payroll tax – leading example: SA
  • Harmonised payroll tax rulings – leading example: NSW
  • Low or no land tax on commercial property – leading examples: ACT, NT, SA
  • No stamp duty on commercial property – leading example: SA
  • No insurance duties – leading example: ACT
  • Low workers’ compensation premiums – leading example: QLD
  • Unrestricted retail trading hours – leading examples: ACT, NT
  • Lean business licensing – leading example: SA

 

Planning systems:

  • Deemed approvals – leading example: QLD
  • Limits on stopping the clock – leading examples: QLD, WA
  • Coordinated referrals – leading examples: QLD, WA, NSW
  • Timeframes across the whole process – leading example: TAS
  • Deemed-to-comply housing code – leading example: VIC
  • One planning instrument – leading examples: SA, NT
  • Set development contributions – leading example: ACT
  • Open data and one portal – leading example: NSW

 

Regulation Rumble is based on research by planning professionals, together with the BCA’s economists and policy experts. The rankings are based on analysis of current settings as at mid‑2026, including state and territory budgets and current legislation, together with outcome data that provides real-world planning system performance. Regulation Rumble 2026 is focused on the performance and policies in place as at mid‑2026, policies that have been announced, but are not yet in place, are not captured in the rankings.

To learn more about the rankings and key findings, download the report.

case study

A Brisbane café – 31 steps to pour a coffee

The Productivity Commission’s December 2025 inquiry report on Creating a more dynamic and resilient economy observed that a would-be café owner in Brisbane “has to engage with so many different approvals, licences and government departments that the City Council has created a series of checklists with as many as 31 steps before the business owner can even contemplate charging $5 for a flat white”. This vignette follows that owner through the process as it stands on Brisbane City Council’s website in August 2026.

What the count captures
Regulation Rumble 2026 counts 29 obligations for a Queensland café: 17 licences and approvals, of which nine are council and eight state; six codes of practice; and six regulatory obligations. The count and the Commission’s 31 steps measure different things. The obligation count is therefore a conservative measure of process. It records the number of distinct regulatory instruments a café must satisfy, not the number of interactions required to satisfy them.

To learn more about Regulation Rumble 2026, download the report.